Another sandstorm today forces me to stay inside and read news on the internet. All the coverage lately is in regards to Gen McChrystal etal's ill-thought comments on the Obama administration's approach to war policy. If you haven't read the article at the center of the storm, you can find it at http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/37847841/ns/us_news-military//.
Before reading it, I was not sure how the President would approach the controversy. Is it better to slap the wrist but maintain continuity in your war effort by keeping the general in place? Is it better to establish Presidential authority and accept his resignation, finding a new general to lead the war? After reading the article, Gen McChrystal comes across as a Testosterone-drunk cowboy, loose at war. I, for one, will be curious to see what the President decides.
On a slightly related note, a documentary called Restrepo is being released in the US in July (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/20/movies/20restrepo.html?scp=2&sq=restrepo&st=cse ). I believe that distribution will be limited to NY and LA, however, a few army bases will also screen it. I would love to see it - I read the related articles in Vanity Fair at the time they were release and have been to Afghanistan (of course). I have tried to find an email address for the guys in charge (Sebastian Junger and Tim Heatherington) to send a patriotic email and request the chance to see it over here. However, a lot of sites are blocked on gov't computers. If anyone can find an email address or, even better, knows someone who knows someone, I would really like to see that documentary. And screening it for troops in theater sounds patriotic -right?
As a late addition to this post, by now it is clear that Obama accepted/forced McChrystal's resignation. I think that was the only tenable move. Can Petraeus do for Afghanistan what he did for Iraq? I hope so - our guys are really taking a beating.
Wednesday, June 23, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Deployed in Place
Ben pointed out this morning that the blog may be a good way to stay in touch and keep people up to date. I used it for a similar purpose ...
-
Turns out that arrival day in Germany was very interesting. Through a combination of luck, frequent flyer's miles and good standing wit...
-
I am forced to make a correction. In an attempt to highlight a cute rodent, I inadvertently posted a photo of a cute mouse, rather than a h...
-
Another sandstorm today forces me to stay inside and read news on the internet. All the coverage lately is in regards to Gen McChrystal eta...
4 comments:
I looked up both of those guys. You can reach Tim Hetherington at tim@timhetherington.com.
Couldn't find a direct email for Sebastian Junger, only Facebook and Twitter accounts.
If you want to facebook Junger for me, that would be cool. I don't have a facebook account and refuse to get one. If not, it's okay (it's a long-shot anyway). Thanks for the other email, I'll try it.
The Rolling Stone article is stunning. This man should not have been in the position he was and Obama did what he had to do in removing him. I have more confidence in Petraeus by an order of magnitude but He's not God and I just don't see a good outcome as even a remote possibility in Afghanistan.
There's no contact information on Mr. Junger's Facebook or Twitter accounts. Apparently he doesn't appreciate feedback.
Post a Comment